Which Fitness Tracker Should You Buy? WHOOP vs Oura Ring vs Regular Trackers

09/10/2024

Choosing the right fitness tracker can feel like a daunting task. There’s so much out there, and let’s be honest—each one claims to be the best. Today, we’re comparing three popular options: the WHOOP, the Oura Ring, and your classic, everyday fitness trackers. Whether you're an athlete, a wellness enthusiast, or someone just getting started on their fitness journey, knowing what to look for is key. So, let’s break it down.

Share:

1. WHOOP: The Athlete's Choice

If you're serious about improving performance and tracking recovery, WHOOP has a strong reputation among athletes and fitness fanatics. The device itself doesn't have a screen (which might surprise some), but that’s intentional. WHOOP isn’t about step counting or flashy features—it’s focused on helping you optimise recovery, sleep, and strain.

It’s designed to be worn 24/7 and collects data that help you understand how much strain you’ve put your body under and how well you’ve recovered overnight. The insights go deep: sleep stages, heart rate variability (HRV), and respiratory rate are just a few metrics WHOOP excels at tracking. The data is then delivered to your phone, which means there’s no need to constantly check your wrist.

Who it's best for:

If you're someone who pushes your body regularly—whether through sport, intense fitness routines, or you’re training for an event—WHOOP offers some of the most comprehensive recovery and performance tracking available.

Downside:

WHOOP is subscription-based, and it’s not cheap. Plus, because there’s no screen, you’re reliant on your phone for all your data insights, which some might find less convenient.

2. Oura Ring: Sleep and Wellness in Style

If aesthetics matter to you, the Oura Ring has one clear advantage over traditional fitness trackers: it’s not bulky. This sleek ring packs a lot of tech into a small design and focuses mainly on sleep and overall wellness rather than hardcore fitness tracking.

What sets Oura apart is its highly detailed sleep tracking, which it uses to inform you about your recovery and readiness for the day ahead. It also tracks your activity, heart rate, and body temperature, giving you a well-rounded picture of your health. Unlike WHOOP, which is more about optimising performance, Oura strikes a balance between activity and rest, making it a solid choice for those focused on lifestyle wellness rather than fitness gains.

Who it's best for:

If you're more concerned with improving your sleep, managing stress, and keeping an eye on your overall wellness, Oura offers a comprehensive yet stylish way to track your health. It's subtle enough for daily wear without screaming “fitness tracker.”

Downside:

It’s not great for high-performance athletes. While it tracks activity and heart rate, it's not as granular or immediate as something like WHOOP or a regular fitness tracker during exercise.

3. Regular Fitness Trackers: The All-Rounder

If you're after something more mainstream that’ll give you a mix of both fitness and health tracking, regular fitness trackers like Fitbit or Garmin may be your best bet. These trackers offer a wide range of functions, including step counting, calories burned, heart rate monitoring, and sleep tracking—all displayed in real-time.

Most of these trackers come with a screen, so you can check your stats at a glance without needing your phone. Some models, like the Garmin Venu or the Fitbit Charge, even include GPS, which is a big plus for runners or cyclists who want to map their routes. Plus, they tend to be more budget-friendly compared to WHOOP or the Oura Ring, especially since there's no monthly subscription fee.

Who it’s best for:

If you’re looking for a practical, all-round fitness tracker without the hefty price tag or extra subscriptions, traditional trackers are ideal. They’re easy to use, usually include multiple health metrics, and are perfect for someone just looking to stay active or meet general fitness goals.

Downside:

While great for basic fitness tracking, they don’t dive as deep into recovery and wellness as WHOOP or Oura, which may matter more if you're looking for those specific insights.

Which One Should You Buy?

It all comes down to your goals. If you’re an athlete or someone who takes performance and recovery seriously, WHOOP might be worth the investment. If you want a wellness tracker that blends into your life without sacrificing style (or comfort), the Oura Ring is a strong contender. But if you’re just looking for a versatile and easy-to-use fitness tracker, a regular model like Fitbit or Garmin is probably all you need.

Ultimately, the best tracker is the one that fits your lifestyle and keeps you motivated to stay active and healthy.

Beatriz Ribeiro - BSc (hons), MSc, RD
Alyve Head Nutritionist

Want to see what nutrients your body needs?

Take Quiz
Questions?
Social
Subscribe and stay up-to-date on Alyve news, exclusive offers, and more.
© 2024 Alyve Wellness. All rights reserved.